The Eclectic Readers

Book Lists Book sellers Writing Services Quotes Links

What are the best series ever written? The series that most consistently maintained a high level of story telling and character development?

Here are the eclectic reader choices:

  1. Sherlock Holmes. No series has ever maintained such a consistent quality of story, captured such a sense of place in the consciousness of English language people. This is the classic of mystery writing. And Doyle didn't even like his character.
  2. Harry Potter. Rowling has done something that no one else has ever done. She has written a fresh character that captured both the youth and the adult audiences with great characters and great story telling.
  3. Nero Wolfe. Rex stout created more than a character. He developed a location and a cast that would play well against each new mystery. Nero Wolfe would not have been a series star without the list of supporting characters that played so well in contrast.
  4. Travis McGee. MacDonald's suave character who took his retirement in increments voiced every guys secret dreams. Good stories and even better characters.
  5. Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee mysteries by Tony Hillerman. How can you beat the setting, the Indian culture and two wonderful characters who play off each other and the life of the reservation.
  6. Skink - when Karl Hiasson has this outrageous character in his novels there is nothing funnier in print.
  7. Kinsey Milhone. This one is tough. I loved the first 9, hated the next 8, and have been neutral since then. Sometimes a character exceeds the authors story. This is one series I wish had stopped early.
  8. James Bond
  9. The Sackett's by Louis L'Amour
  10. Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys
  11. Miss Marple - Agatha Christie
  12. Hercule Poirot - Agatha Christie

The best of 2006 - so far this year these are our favorites:

  1. River of Doubt. Candace Millard. This is the story of an extraordinary journey that T. Roosevelt completed on a river in the Amazon after his loss in the presidential race. It is a story of an amazing American and an equally dramatic exploration.
  2. A Plague of Frogs, William Souder not only writes well, but he is able to take a really complex situation like the deformed frogs of southern MN that started an international inquiry in to frog demise and deformity all over the world and make both the frogs and scientists into players in a morality play worthy of the classic ancient play by Aristophanes - The Frogs.
  3. Field Notes from a Catastrophe, Elizbeth Kellert. An excellent sample of the events all around the world, and the scientists who are studying them, that cummulatively show the impending dangers of global warming. Well done. Informative. Not too preachy. A good book to read if you have any doubts.
  4. Manhunt, James Swanson. I thought I knew about the Lincoln assasination and John Wilkes Boothe. Well I was wrong. This is both enlightening and engaging. What great story telling.
  5. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, J. D. Rowling. This is the first book where the movie does not come close to the story. The complex layers are fun and well balanced in a story that is sure to be pivotal in the series.
  6. Amalgamation Polka, Stephen Wright. The Odyssey set in the Civil War. A very American story - extraordinarily plain characters and a compelling new look at the Civil War and the players.
  7. Becoming a Tiger, Susan McCarthy. You know, it really isn't easy becoming what we are. I mean, without a mirror, how do we know what we are? Look at the trials and errors of various critters as they attempt to be what their parents were.
  8. A Team of Rivals, Doris Kearns. I thought I had read all the Lincoln I needed to. After all these years, what else was there to know. But Doris Kearn gives a fresh perspective, not a direct biography of Lincoln, but a mirror created by the very complex cabinet that he created. Here for the first time is Lincoln, manager of men.
  9. Marley and Me, John Grogan. This is a book about a dog, not a show dog, a working dog, a hero dog. Not even a well trained dog, just a big goofy yellow lab and the family he became part of. A mix of tears and laughs and scenes that every yellow lab owner can relate to. The best dog book in years.
  10. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban by J. D. Rowling maintains the high quality of fantasy and writing that has marked this entire series.
  11. Tales to Astonish, Ronin Ro is a great look at the history of comic books and the edgy relationship of Stan Lee, Jack Kirby and Marvel Comics. If you liked comics like I did - this is a must read story.
  12. Crack in the Edge of the World, Simon Winchesters outstanding look at the 1906 San Francisco earthquake.
  13. Don't Stuff the Dog, Alan Alda's autobiography was easy to read, enlightening and enjoyable. We just wished there had been a few more MASH antidotes.
  14. S is for Silence, Sue Grafton. I got hooked early by Sue Grafton novels and I really liked A - I, but J - R has been a challenge. I nearly gave up, but that would have been a shame because S revived some of the fun of the early books. Good characterization which was always the strong point and a mystery that was good enough to keep the characters engaged.
  15. Neither Here Nor There, Bill Bryson. A trip around Europe. Overall enjoyable, but sometimes he is too cynical and tries to hard for humor. There times I think he must walk around with a kick me sign on his back. I just returned from five weeks in Europe, in some of the places he writes about and found it spectacular. Mr Bryson comes on as a displaced Iowan who is trying to move through the world under the cloak of an Englishman.
  16. The Great Age of Discovery, Paul Herrmann does a good job of bringing Cortes, Columbus and Pizzaro to life and almost makes me admire them despite the destruction they wrought.
  17. Sleeping with the Devil. Robert Baer is ex-CIA and brings a frightening insight into our relationship with Saudi Arabia and the oil barons.
  18. Whale Season, N. M. Kelly. Wow - talk about fun fluff. I know you can read lessons in to some of the work, but in reality, this is just a case of putting a group of characters - mostly zany losers - into a bag - Whale Harbor - and shaking the container so that blues singer, strip joint owner, loser sheriff, loser salesman, and others have to react to new realities. This is a very enjoyable read.
  19. Eragon bvy CHristopher Paolini is like sitting at a Dungeon and Dragon table. Well written by this young author, it does not have the depth of other fantasy books that dominate the best seller list this year.
  20. Above the Clouds by Boukreev the Russian climber that was vilifiled in the Krakauer book about the tragedy at Everest. This book gives more insight in to a mountain man, a driven climber, and perhaps a man misjudged by many.
  21. Stalking the Angel by RObert Clais is a wonderful mystery. Light, well paced with interesting characters

A recommendation: I highly recommend "The Trout Pool Paradox" for a good book about rivers and history! Cheers, John Helland

Favorite libraries:

Kenosha Taylors Falls Betty Brinn children's library, Milwaukee

Kenosha looks like it is the capital of libraries. Taylors Falls is an 1888 home making books the possession of everyone.

Book Quotes for the Month

A Dog’s History of America, Mark Derr, North Point Press, 2004.
After the grueling years of war and the satisfaction of victory, foxes and wolves would seem minor annoyances, yet they stood in Washington's way, obstacles to creating a smoothly operating farm where all was in balance. Washington evidently disliked such obstructions, whether harmful to his crops or animals, to transport by land or sea, or to success in battle or politics. A few years after obtaining the French hounds, he attempted to find dogs to help him kill wolves that were threatening his prized sheep.
The problem of sheep-killing canids was as old as European settlement in North America, but it no longer involved the survival of a few colonists and a handful of sheep. Now planters like Washington and Jefferson, who were not devoted solely to monocropping tobacco, rice, indigo, or cotton, and farmers from New England and western nonslave territories, were more intent on improving the quality of their sheep, other livestock, and even their dogs than their forebears had been a century before. Sheep meant wool for homespun clothes, which freed many pioneers from reliance on settlements, as well as a source of revenue, especially if the wool was high quality. Sheep also meant cheese, lamb, and mutton. The emphasis therefore shifted from mere survival to something more sophisticated, to notions of scientific breeding for quantity and quality, both of which required more time and intensive effort on the part of the farmer. As the value of the livestock increased, so did the importance of protecting it from predators.
At Monticello, Jefferson complained regularly about the depredations of wolves and dogs in northern Virginia—dogs alone in southern Virginia—preventing the sheep population from growing and farmers from achieving greater self-sufficiency. The yeoman farmer was the backbone of the republic for Jefferson, and he saw improvement of livestock—and even people—through selective breeding, as well as scientific farming methods involving crop rotation and fertilization, as central to the success of the people and nation. Although Washington and Jefferson sought the assistance of dogs, they found no easy solution and continued to fight the problem for the remainder of their lives, as did many sheepmen before and more after. After extirpation of the wolf from nearly all of the lower forty-eight states, the coyote became the favorite bandit predator of sheep ranchers, and without question, coyotes can and do take sheep. But in many areas the star sheep killer was always the dog, fearing no human or domesticated beast, smart enough to let its wild cousins take the rap.

The Singing Life of Birds. Donald Kroodsma, Houghton Mifflin, 2005

I record and record, rilling tape after tape; then I film, song after song, their tiny photographs soon covering every surface in my office. The results \ leave no doubt. The marsh wrens prove adept at imitating the details of songs from the training tape, learning not only marsh wren songs but a few of those of the other three species as well. Nine out of 10 songs developed by these marsh wrens are imitations of songs on the training tape, only 1 in 10 being sufficiently different that I cannot know its origin. But the sedge wrens are polar opposites. One male has 20 songs, one 60 songs, and one 70 songs; none of these 150 songs are what they heard from the tape. There's some evidence that they might learn a little from each other, but the vast majority of the songs seem to be pulled out of thin air, somehow improvised in the mind of each young bird.
But why? Why the striking difference between these close relatives? Jerry and I reflect on the life history of each, searching for clues. They are similar in many ways: males of each are polygynous, each male trying to attract several females; in their bid for success, males sing rapidly, throughout the day and often even the night; and perhaps because they are polygynous and sing a lot, their song repertoires are large.
In one key life history feature, however, they seem to differ. Sedge wrens live in sedge meadows and are highly unpredictable from year to year, almost seeming to be nomadic. A friend bands 10 adults in Minnesota but finds none of them back the next year. In Michigan, too, birds are opportunistic, taking advantage of good habitat when and where it appears. In Iowa they might arrive to breed in July, August, or even as late as September; in Arkansas babies are in the nest during September. At these times, most other songbirds have long since finished all family activities. In contrast, marsh wrens live in the deep-water marshes and are more typical songbirds: many are resident year-round, and if migratory they typically return to the same places year after year.
The explanation seems simple, almost too simple. Marsh wrens live in stable habitats, the deep-water marshes, and as a result are resident or at least site-faithful. The singing males in a stable community all know each other, and they learn their songs from each other, as seems to happen with most songbirds. These learned songs are then a crucial part of the countersinging games that the males play in their attempts to secure both a territory and mates.
The sedge wrens are different. They move around a lot, seemingly always in search of a better sedge meadow, the quality of which is dependent on rain fall. Conditions may be prime at one site in one month, but the next month the birds may have moved hundreds of miles to breed at a new location. As a result, birds never get to know each other. Because it is an impossible task to learn hundreds of different songs from the new neighbors at each breeding location, perhaps twice each spring and summer, they do the next best thing. They make them up.

 

Advertising policy: We will accept advertisements that help promote quality books, good writing, literature, independent bookstores, small publishers. We hope to eventually have a large number of Independent booksellers, publishers, writers, consultants on this web page and make it a real tool for writing and reading enthusiasts. Contact us at mikelink45@hotmail.com for details.

We offer a separate page and a monthly page update to book stores and other small market book services and we hope that by adding a variety of bookstores you will market books for one another. Each separate page will have your own list of recommended books, contact information, and a calendar of events.

 

Sig listens to Mike

45@hotmail.com That is why Sigurd and I engage in reading regularly.

Read and be free, read and break the barriers - knowledge really is power - no wonder there are many who would prefer that you just turn on the tube.

The eclectic readers will help you through the maze - visit our site often, learn about good books, great books, and a few not so good groups as we share our experience and add the insights of friends and site visitors.

Check out the tribute to Jules Verne in the March Smithsonian magazine - nice bio on a classic author.

Check out Mike's recommendations - the best books read in 2005 and other years as well as by genre. Then check out the quotes to get a sample of the writing and good pithy paragraphs of text.


A new reader in the family. Check our Matthew's reading habits. Mike trying to explain a good book to Aren.

Contact Information

The Eclectic Reader is a part of The Eclectic Travelers.com, LLC
Mike Link, CEO
mikelink45@hotmail.com